Hiring a Hotel General Manager? 3 Essential Questions

Insights Worth Savoring

Receive hand-picked industry data, salary guides, and talent highlights!


Hotel Leaders Survey the New Lobby

Written by April Taylor

April Taylor is a Founding Partner at The Reserve Talent Group, where she brings deep recruiting expertise, strong intuition, and a people-first approach to every search. Known for her ability to navigate complex hiring needs with confidence and care, April is a trusted partner to clients looking for the right fit, not just a quick fill.

November 14, 2026

If you’re hiring a hotel general manager, picture what you’ll ask them to do in their first week.

At a luxury resort reopening after a renovation, the new GM might spend that week walking through the guest experience with department heads. Room rates are going up, the restaurant has a new concept, and guests will expect both the service and the setting to feel worth the price.

At another property, rooms revenue is on plan, but repeat guests are reporting slower service and two department heads have left six weeks before peak season. That GM has to find out where service is breaking down and decide what the team can realistically fix before the rush.

Both properties could interview the same impressive candidate. Asking what the property needs from its next GM gives ownership a better way to judge whose experience fits the job.

What to Look for When Hiring a Hotel General Manager

For a relaunch, look for someone who can deliver on the new guest promise. Ask how the candidate prepared front desk, housekeeping, and food and beverage teams for a reopening or repositioning. What did they see during the first few weeks that made them adjust the plan? Listen for examples of how they worked across departments, especially when one part of the experience was ready before the others.

For a turnaround, look for someone who can set priorities under pressure. Ask about a time the candidate inherited slipping service scores, leadership vacancies, or a department struggling to meet its financial targets. Find out how they diagnosed the problem, what they addressed first, and how they knew their changes were helping.

For a transition after a longtime GM leaves, look for someone who can earn the team’s trust. An incoming GM inherits relationships with employees, repeat guests, and ownership. Ask how the candidate got to know an established team, which traditions they preserved, and how they handled the first change they knew would be unpopular.

3 Essential Questions to Ask Every Hotel GM Finalist

Give each finalist the same short, anonymized scenario. Rooms revenue is on plan, repeat guests are noticing slower service, two department-head roles are open, and peak season is six weeks away.

  1. What would you verify in your first week? Listen for what they’d check in guest feedback, staffing schedules, and conversations with department leads before drawing a conclusion.
  2. What would you tackle before peak season, and what would you give more time? Ask them to explain how they’d weigh immediate service improvements against the time and attention their team has available.
  3. What decision would you need ownership to make, and by when? Their answer can show whether they know how to work with ownership when the clock is ticking.

Then ask for a comparable example from their career. If they say they improved service while controlling labor costs, ask what changed on the floor and how they measured both outcomes. Those details give you something specific to follow up on in reference conversations.

For more on asking candidates the same questions and evaluating their answers consistently, see the U.S. Office of Personnel Management’s guide to structured interviews.

Decide What the New GM Can Approve

Before interviewing, agree on who can approve department-head hires, staffing changes, and vendor commitments. For a relaunch, tell finalists which renovation milestones and opening dates are firm. For a turnaround, clarify who can authorize changes to staffing or service before peak season.

These decisions affect what a GM can reasonably deliver in the first 90 days. If ownership needs to sign off on filling two vacant leadership roles, for example, candidates should know who makes that decision and how quickly it can happen.

When Should You Bring in a Hospitality Executive Search Partner?

A search partner can help when you need to approach sitting GMs discreetly or when the role calls for operating experience that’s hard to find. A resort relaunch may call for someone who has coordinated an opening across rooms, dining, and spa. A turnaround may call for someone who has rebuilt a department leadership team while keeping a busy property running.

The Reserve Talent Group recruits senior leaders for luxury hotels, resorts, and destination properties. If you’re preparing for a relaunch, working through a turnaround, or replacing a longtime GM, we can help you define the role and find leaders who have handled comparable work. Talk with The Reserve about your search.

Insights Worth Savoring

Receive hand-picked industry data, salary guides, and talent highlights!


You May Also Like…